11 Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers (Nearly Indestructible)

Updated January 30, 2022
We hope you enjoy the products we have selected for you. Our editorial team has independently curated this list, and you can find out more about our review process here. LoveToKnow may collect a commission on purchases made through the links below.
Happy Dog Running with Ball Outdoors

One of the great joys of owning a dog is watching them play. But for some dogs, playing with toys is an exercise in mass destruction. This means extra cleanup for you, and it can put your dog at risk for harm. The good news is, there's a great selection of (nearly) indestructible dog toys that will keep you and your pup happy no matter how much they chew.

Our Top Durable Dog Toy Picks


Best Choice for Swimmers:
5. West Paw Zogoflex Hurley

Unlike most other tough toys, Zogoflex material is both durable and lightweight, so it'll float in the water.
Read more.

Best Choice for Puppies:
8. Ruff Dawg Indestructible Dawg-Nut Dog Toy

The Dawg-Nut ring is tough on chewing but gentle on teeth, so it's perfect for teething puppies and adult dogs alike.
Read more.

Best Choice for Ball Lovers:
6. Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Ball

This bouncy, textured ball is made of TPE rubber, so it can withstand the most aggressive chewers.
Read more.

Best Choice to Deter Destructive Chewing:
9. Playology Scented Dual Layer Bone

Playology's innovative scent technology helps promote chewing on this tough toy instead of inappropriate items.
Read more.

Best Plush Toy Choice:
11. goDog Furballz Squeaky Plush Toy

This plush toy is reinforced with a durable liner, known as Chew Guard Technology, to make it longer lasting than other soft toys.
Read more.

Best Choice for Stick Lovers:
7. Petstages Dogwood Chew Stick

Composed of natural wood fibers and synthetic material, this durable chew toy tastes like a real stick without the risks.
Read more.
GoughNuts Ring Dog Toy

GoughNuts Ring Dog Toy

Goughnuts rubber chew toys are designed by a team of engineers to be "virtually indestructible." They're composed of carbon-reinforced rubber for extra durability and consist of two layers, which contribute to their unique safety feature.

The inside layer of a Goughnut product is a red color, and if your dog chews on one enough to reveal the red core, this is a sign the toy's integrity has been compromised and it's time to retire it. This will keep your dog from unintentionally swallowing a piece of the toy, which is why so many veterinarians recommend Goughnuts. Make sure you take a look at the ring every so often to confirm no red is visible, then let your dog go nuts.

Goughnuts toys are available as rings or sticks and come in different strengths based on a dog's size or chewing power. Original Goughnuts toys are great for swimmers because they float, but the "Pro" line (recognizable by a bright yellow spot on the toy) will sink in water.

What We Like
Includes a safety indicator, so you know when the toy is too damaged to chew
Durable carbon-reinforced rubber
Original style can float in water
Available in different strengths
What We Don't
Even the Small size may be too large for dogs under 10 pounds
Advertisement

When it comes to heavy-duty toys, you can't go wrong with KONG products. The KONG Extreme is made specifically for aggressive chewers because these toys can take a beating without breaking into pieces. They are made from durable black rubber and come in several sizes.

The brand has been creating tough chew toys since the 1970s, and they're widely recommended by veterinarians, canine behavior specialists, dog trainers, and frequently used in shelters due to their durability. vetSTREET praises the toy for its sturdiness and affordability, calling it the "hardest working dog toy under $10."

Another great feature of the KONG line of toys is that you can stuff them with food, peanut butter, or treats to make your dog work for a reward. Some owners even freeze stuffed KONGs for a refreshing snack that keeps dogs occupied for quite a while. KONG toys come in a range of sizes from S (for dogs under 20 pounds) to XXL (dogs 85 pounds and up).

What We Like
Highly recommended by vets and canine experts
Can be stuffed with food, treats, peanut butter, etc.
BPA-free and dishwasher safe
Several available sizes
What We Don't
Some dogs have difficulty picking it up due to the shape
Busy Buddy Barnacle Treat Dispenser

Busy Buddy Barnacle Treat Dispenser

The Busy Buddy line by Petsafe has several durable toy options. While some of them contain hard plastic or nylon that can damage your dog's teeth, the Barnacle is made of safer heavy rubber, so it can still withstand the most aggressive chewers. But this product isn't just a chew toy; it's also a treat dispenser with three compartments.

This feature encourages chewing, keeps your pup mentally stimulated, and cleans their teeth while providing them with a delicious treat, too. While the snacks you place inside might not last long, this strong toy will hold up through endless gnawing without becoming shredded.

The Barnacle Treat Dispenser is available in sizes Small, Medium, and Large; choose the appropriate one based on your dog's weight. Oh, and did we mention it can be placed in the top rack of the dishwasher for easy cleaning? Score!

What We Like
Serves as a treat dispenser with three compartments
Interactive and keeps dogs busy
Top rack dishwasher safe
Durable rubber material
What We Don't
Compartments and grooves can become dirty quickly, so regular cleaning is necessary
Monster K9 Ultra-Durable Flying Disc

Monster K9 Ultra-Durable Flying Disc

For aggressive chewers who love chasing frisbees, the Monster K9 Flying Disc is a great option. Their disc is made with industrial-strength rubber so it can hold up to gnawing between throws. The brand boasts puncture-resistant material that will stay smooth for easy gliding.

Note that because this flyer is composed of durable rubber, it weighs slightly more than a plastic Frisbee (8 ounces and approximately 6 ounces, respectively). While your dog gets to work out their chewing on the toy, you may also get a bit of a workout with your throwing arm. The flying disc is available in one strength and size.

What We Like
Great for dogs who like to chase Frisbees
Non-toxic, industrial-strength rubber
What We Don't
Slightly heavier than a traditional plastic disc
Only one size available
Does not float in water
Advertisement
West Paw Zogoflex Hurley

West Paw Zogoflex Hurley

West Paw created its innovative Zogoflex material to hold up to strong and long chew sessions. It's also latex-free and made from recyclable materials. We love the Hurley style because the slender shape makes it a great option for throwing, fetching, or just hanging out and chewing, if that's what your dog prefers.

Stick-loving dogs go especially wild for this chew toy, and owners can enjoy peace of mind knowing it won't break off into dangerous splinters. The sturdy, lightweight material also floats, so it's a great alternative to throwing sticks while splashing around. The Hurley comes in three sizes based on your dog's size: Extra-Small, Small, and Large.

What We Like
Composed of non-toxic, BPA-free, FDA-compliant, recycled materials
Bounces and floats on water
Shape is great for stick-lovers
Available in bright colors so they're easy to see
Top rack dishwasher safe.
What We Don't
Doesn't squeak
Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Ball

Planet Dog Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate Ball

The Orbee-Tuff Diamond Plate toys are made from thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) rubber, so they're flexible yet can withstand the most aggressive chewers. This ball gets 5 out of 5 on Planet Dog's own durability "Chew-o-Meter," which earned it the title of the top spot as their toughest Orbee-Tuff product yet. It's composed of a single piece of rubber, so there are no seams or points of weakness. It also floats and is bouncy for hours of fun.

Busy dogs who need some extra mental stimulation can benefit from the ball's ability to act as a treat dispenser. Just toss some snacks in the treat reservoir and your pup will be occupied for hours. The strong rubber material is mint-scented to leave your dog's breath smelling fresh after chewing. It's available in two sizes (3-inch or 4-inch), so make your selection based on your dog's size.

What We Like
Made of non-toxic and durable TPE rubber
Ball chasers love the round shape
Can place snacks inside to use as a treat dispenser
Floats and bounces
What We Don't
Some dogs are adverse to the minty scent
Petstages Dogwood Chew Stick

Petstages Dogwood Chew Stick

Petstages combine strong synthetic material with natural wood fibers to create this stick alternative. Dogs who love gnawing on branches are attracted to the real wood smell and flavor of the Dogwood stick. And thanks to the polymer material, it won't splinter into sharp pieces that could pierce a dog's mouth or throat.

Keep in mind, this toy will wear down over time with aggressive chewing, so you'll need to replace it as it wears. There's also a chance your dog could potentially damage their teeth on the hard material, so remove it if your dog gnaws too vigorously. However, for the dog who has a natural urge to chew on twigs or wood, this product is a much safer alternative.

It's available in multiple sizes, from Petite to Large. Take careful note of the measurements for each when making your selection, because the Petite is quite short at only 4 inches in length. Even tiny dogs may be safer with size Small or larger.

What We Like
Safer alternative to chewing on sticks
Smells and tastes like real wood
Floats in the water
What We Don't
Hard synthetic material can damage teeth
Petite size is very small
Advertisement
Ruff Dawg Indestructible Dawg-Nut Dog Toy

Ruff Dawg Indestructible Dawg-Nut Dog Toy

If the name doesn't convince you of how indestructible this dog toy is, this product consistently withstands powerful chewers who can usually tear through toys like they're tissue. The Dawg-Nut is made of solid FDA-approved rubber that won't damage your dog's teeth or gums. Puppies love the springy material for teething, and the donut shape is great for tossing, bouncing, or carrying.

If things get messy, just rinse the toy down with water or pop it in the dishwasher for easy cleanup. Dogs and puppies under 40 pounds can use the Regular size, whereas larger dogs should pick the Extra Large. And if the donut shape doesn't appeal to your pet, Ruff Dawg offers the same indestructible material in other designs.

What We Like
Safe for teething puppies
Latex and BPA-free
Bounces and floats
What We Don't
May be too large for very small breed dogs or puppies
Playology Scented Dual Layer Bone

Playology Scented Dual Layer Bone

If your goal in finding a durable dog toy is to prevent your dog from chewing on other things, Playology's revolutionary scented toys can help. Their products feature Encapsiscent Technology, which means the materials are embedded on a microscopic level with enticing scents. This keeps your dog coming back to this chew toy instead of turning to your favorite pair of shoes.

Of the Playology chew toys, the Dual Layer Bone is designed specifically for heavy chewers. Pick the appropriate size for your dog (Small, Medium, or Large). If you're unsure which scent to get, try chicken - it's a fan favorite.

What We Like
Revolutionary embedded scent keeps dogs engaged
Great for redirecting inappropriate chewing
Safe, durable rubber material
Various scents and sizes available
What We Don't
Higher price point
Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Dental Toy

Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Dental Toy

Any product that can keep your dog busy while benefiting their health is a win, and the Arm & Hammer dental toys fulfill both. These strong rubber toys are designed for tough chewers, so they're made to last. Plus, the material is infused with baking soda to help clean your dog's teeth and freshen their breath.

While the deep ridges are designed to reduce plaque on the teeth during chewing, they can also attract food and dirt. Fortunately, this toy can go right into the dishwasher. Make sure you give it a deep clean often. The Treadz dental toys only come in two sizes: Small (dogs up to 25 pounds) and Large (dogs up to 35 pounds).

What We Like
Infused baking soda and ridges clean teeth and freshen breath
Dishwasher safe
What We Don't
Not recommended for dogs over 35 pounds
Advertisement
goDog Furballz Squeaky Plush Toy

goDog Furballz Squeaky Plush Toy

Every dog has their own preferences, and some simply prefer plush toys over rubber. But tough chewers don't have to be deprived of soft toys, because goDog's Furballz ball features the company's Chew Guard technology, which makes the material tough and durable. Seams are also double stitched, and the squeaker is built-in.

While the Furballz toy does contain stuffing, the reinforced fabric helps prevent tearing. The manufacturer is so confident in its Chew Guard layer, it even offers a 30-day guarantee. This bright, rainbow-colored plush comes in three different sizes (Tiny, Small, and Large). Spot wash as needed and allow to air dry.

What We Like
Soft, cuddly material for dogs who prefer plush toys
Reinforced seams and Chew Guard liner to prevent ripping
Built-in squeaker
Three sizes available
What We Don't
Must be spot cleaned
Does contain stuffing

Choosing Safe, Indestructible Dog Toys

While it's necessary to choose toys that chewers can't destroy so they don't swallow any parts, it's equally important to review the hardness of each toy. Unfortunately, many products out there are not safe because they contain hard materials like plastic or nylon. These can result in broken teeth or oral damage if a dog chews vigorously enough. That's why the products on this list are primarily made of durable rubber or other safe materials.

Even so, it's always important to keep a close eye on your dog after giving them a new chew toy, no matter how tough it is. This way, you can intervene if the toy becomes a danger. Check toys regularly for wear and tear, and replace them as needed. Whether your dog is a chaser, tugger, or food-motivated treat-finder, there's a durable option that should last through their aggressive gnawing. Good luck chew-sing just one!

Was this page useful?
11 Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers (Nearly Indestructible)